All writing

In Pursuit of Merit

Jordan Ott14 min read

The secret of my success is that we have gone to exceptional lengths to hire the best people in the world. — Steve Jobs

The concept of social and economic mobility based on merit was a revolutionary change in the structure of human societies, and it occurred relatively recently in human history. For most of recorded history, society was a rigid hierarchy where an individual’s position was determined by birth. This began to change with the enlightenment, culminating in the social transformations in Britain, France, and the United States. While many of these ideas originated across the Atlantic they were embraced to a large degree in the colonies and early American states. In fact, the American Revolution can be viewed as a direct rejection of a non-meritocratic form of government, the British monarchy.

This pursuit of merit was evident from the country’s inception, as Alexander Hamilton wrote in Federalist 36, “There are strong minds in every walk of life that will rise superior to the disadvantages of situation, and will command the tribute due to their merit, not only from the classes to which they particularly belong, but from the society in general. The door ought to be equally open to all.” Likewise, Thomas Paine commented on the issue of merit writing, “The idea of hereditary legislators is as inconsistent as that of hereditary judges [...] and as absurd as an hereditary mathematician.”

These principles were codified in foundational documents like Article 9 of New Hampshire’s Bill of Rights that stated, “no office or place whatsoever in government shall be hereditary.” The replacement of a rigid social structure and arbitrary selection criteria with a pursuit of merit has gone hand in hand with a general liberation of top down control. This revolutionary change towards merit has given individuals the freedom to compete for desired positions based on their talent and virtues. Alexis de Tocqueville, referring to the pursuit of merit in America, wrote that, “they have opened the door to universal competition.” Getting back to the future requires a reaffirmation of these principles and a rejection of any policy or cultural attitude which seeks to compromise them.

No honest reader of history can suggest that the United States has approached a true meritocracy in its existence. A system where individuals are valued, selected, and promoted based on their individual merits has often not been realized in American history. The institution of slavery clearly lacked any resemblance to valuing individuals based on merit and each group of immigrants faced varying levels of discrimination based on their religion, ethnicity, or land of origin. Many times throughout American history the pursuit of a meritocracy has been abandoned in favor of preferential or exclusionary policies implemented against different ethnic, religious, and political groups. Some prominent examples include Jim Crow laws against American Blacks, occupational restrictions,1 and the racial quotas against Jews in American universities. Over the course of American history there have been both legal and cultural attacks on the meritocracy. This failure on behalf of past generations of Americans continues in our present day. The lesson of merit has not been heeded and this failure has implications for innovation as a result.

The importance of merit driven systems are often viewed from political and legal frameworks, however, the degree to which systems pursue merit as the sole selection criteria directly impacts the course of innovation. Selection systems like job openings, awards, promotions, and college admissions all have direct impacts on the course of technological development. Any selective system has criteria with which it distinguishes one candidate from another. The criteria determine which applicants will receive advanced training, what fields are available, and the level of impact those individuals will have on companies and industries. Selection systems, and the criteria they employ, are often a reflection of the cultural values of individuals. Even when anti-meritocratic policies are enshrined via legislative fiat, they are often done so at the behest of large swaths of the population. Thus the numerous attacks on merit based systems must be viewed as a failure of individuals to internalize the importance of such selection criteria on innovation.

The pursuit of meritocratic systems and merit as a revered cultural value has two important consequences. First, meritocratic systems employ criteria that select candidates based on ability. It may be self-evident to some, but it is indeed desirable to have the most qualified candidates tackling the most challenging problems. There are challenges across many industries that demand our best and brightest to solve them. Second, the importance of merit based systems extends beyond immediate candidate selection. Individuals’ views towards merit influence the selection criteria of systems that eventually determine broader incentive structures. The way that individuals regard merit creates a feedback loop in the system at large. If merit is lauded by the individuals of a society, then it is used as criteria in their institutions, which further creates incentives to be oriented towards merit. When this takes place, individuals are incentivized to improve themselves, thus raising the overall standards and capabilities within the society. This process can lead to a culture of excellence, where the pursuit of knowledge, skill, and achievement becomes a shared goal. In such a merit-based system, education and personal development are highly valued, as they are seen as the primary means of increasing one’s merit. This pursuit of merit can foster a competitive, yet collaborative environment, where the emphasis on merit can drive innovation and efficiency, as individuals and institutions alike seek to optimize their performance.

Selection criteria

Elite teams in the United States military demonstrate the value of merit based selections at one particular extreme of the spectrum. The capability and performance of individuals on a given team, quite literally, is a matter of life and death. Universally revered as one of the most elite groups of soldiers in the world, the Navy Seals have a ruthless selection process where more than 90% of applicants fail to complete basic training. Along the same lines, the United States was successful in the Second World War for many reasons, chief among those was its military leadership.

Prior to 1940, generals were chosen on the basis of seniority. This historical precedent was overturned with FDR’s selection of George Marshall as the Army Chief of Staff. The promotion of Marshall to the highest ranking position bypassed thirty-three more senior generals. In his new post, Marshall was instrumental in persuading congress to remove seniority as the sole qualification for promotion. In a personal letter, Marshall pushed for the ability to select and promote officers based on merit writing,

Officers with knowledge, initiative, drive, and leadership must be placed in important command and staff positions. We have the officers and they can be so placed, provided authority is granted to select and redistribute them without the normal peacetime restrictions as to seniority.2

With the passage of multiple congressional acts in 1940, the Army moved to enforce mandatory retirements for older members as well as selective promotions for more capable leaders. The leadership of the United States military benefited greatly from incorporating merit into its promotion structure. In particular, George Patton and Dwight Eisenhower both benefited from these changes. Patton was spared an early retirement, as the Army was given merit based discretion over forced retirement which allowed it to push out older less capable members. Eisenhower, on the other hand, was promoted rapidly to his ultimate post of Supreme Command of the Allied forces in Europe.

The consequences of merit in the military are far more apparent due to the immediate presence of life threatening situations. However, as we have seen from the history of innovations and their impact on the lives of human beings, the pace of technological progress is also a matter of life and death. As a result, our value of merit should be no different for engineers, scientists, teachers, and doctors.

Over the course of American history, attacks on the meritocracy have taken various forms like seniority based promotions, legacy admissions, racial quotas, and preferential or exclusionary policies in favor of particular groups. In short, any criteria used to select individuals besides direct qualifications or prerequisites is by definition, non-meritocratic. Today, the assault comes from diversity programs or preferential policies for disadvantaged groups. Both types of programs are not meritocratic but substitute various criteria in place of tangible prerequisites and objective merit.

Under the guise of diversity, candidates are selected from varying backgrounds with the purported claim that a more diverse candidate is a more qualified candidate. Yet the connection between diversity and merit is tenuous at best and typically comes with more insidious repercussions. One of the most striking examples came from the University of Michigan’s admissions where, “an Asian with the same GPA and SAT scores as the median black admit had zero chance in 2005 of admission; a white with those same scores had a 1 percent chance of admission.”3

This attack on merit based selections continues into the nation’s medical schools and determines what individuals go on to become doctors and what qualifications they achieve. Referencing data from the Association of American Medical Colleges, The New York Times reported in 2017 that, “For low-range MCAT scores of 24-26 (G.P.A. of 3.2 to 3.4), 57 percent of blacks were admitted, 31 percent of Hispanics, 8 percent of whites and 6 percent of Asians.” In the same article the Times concluded that, “race is a substantial factor in medical school admissions, not one of many.” This of course is entirely backwards, race should be irrelevant and only merit based qualifications should matter. The supremacy of merit is not only legally and morally correct, it yields better results for technology and innovation, as more qualified and skilled individuals earn positions of higher influence.

More recently college admissions, like those in California’s UC system, have been barred from using race as an explicit deciding factor and have instead moved to selecting candidates from “disadvantaged groups.” Students and job seekers from “disadvantaged backgrounds” may very well have overcome incredible obstacles on their personal journey. While this may tell you a great deal about an individual’s resolve, it tells you very little about the concrete skills and prerequisites they meet in order to participate successfully in higher level institutions. None of this is to say that groups targeted by preferential policies are inferior in some cosmic sense. However, particular occupations and professional endeavors often come with numerous prerequisites that must be met prior to participating in a given field or industry. Compromising the meritocracy in the form of preferential policies, regardless of their intentions, serves to disconnect the important process of producing the most qualified candidates that meet and exceed those prerequisites.

The way that individuals in a society view merit is not just an abstract concept but is put into practice through job requirements, hiring committees, college admissions, and other selective programs. Due to inherent constraints, there are often more candidates than there are available spots to fill. As a result, some form of criteria is employed in order to select a limited number of candidates. The people on hiring committees are not oracles capable of seeing the future, they have limited time, resources, and information available to them about prospective applicants. As a result, it is impossible to know with absolute certainty who the optimal candidate is. Knowing this would require selecting all candidates, letting them perform every task, and measuring their accomplishments after the fact. This is rarely feasible, as institutions often have limited resources. However, in response to these constraints, the solution is not to abandon objective merit based criteria, but instead for institutions to become better at evaluating candidates, maximizing the amount of information they can obtain about candidates relative to the position for which they are applying.

In pursuit of arbitrary political goals like equity, some governments and institutions have not only replaced merit as a selection criteria but attacked the very programs which allow for upwards mobility and advanced training. Some local governments and school boards have gone so far as to remove talented and gifted programs in their public schools. Since 2014, San Francisco Unified School District (SFUSD) has embraced “detracking,” a policy that removes the honors and advanced math courses for more talented children. Seattle public schools have likewise moved to eliminate gifted and honors programs, instead placing all students in the same class, regardless of ability. The removal of advanced classes has done little to boost the performance of lower performing students, as the decade long experiment by SFUSD has demonstrated. However, what is achieved is blocking off the advanced training and upwards mobility to more gifted students. These advanced programs have been essential to fast track the development of young students who demonstrate aptitude beyond their age group. The removal of these advanced programs in hopes of leveling the educational playing field is not compassionate nor desirable, as it leaves everyone worse off. The absence of such programs deprive gifted students of reaching their potential as well as depriving all members of society from the fruits of their labor.

Incentive structures

Policies that compromise the meritocracy or favor particular groups for arbitrary reasons often receive a great deal of scrutiny. However, what is often overlooked is the direct impact these policies and preferences have on incentives for individuals. Selection systems with a limited number of spots are often zero sum, meaning that if some candidates are accepted, others must necessarily be rejected. While this description may be true in regard to the physical number of spots, it is far from the case when it comes to the incentive structures that selection systems employ. When merit is the highest value, incentives create positive sum consequences for innovation more broadly.

There are cultural implications from the role merit plays in selection systems. These policies and criteria not only affect individuals actions but also their sentiment towards their fellow members in a society. The below example comes from an article on the preferential policies towards scheduled castes (SC) in India but the same effect is true for selective policies that have been implemented in the United States:

[Suppose] that 300 people qualify for ten posts available. The top nine are appointed on merit but the tenth is reserved, so that the authorities go down the list to find an SC applicant. They find one at 140 and he is appointed. Whereupon all 131 between him and the merit list feel aggrieved. He has not taken 131 posts; he has taken one, yet 131 people believe they have paid the price for it. Moreover, the remaining 159 often also resent the situation, believing that their chances were, somehow, lessened by the existence of SC reservations.4

When merit is not pursued as the sole criteria for selective positions it leads to an increase of animosity towards other members of society. These negative sentiments are capitalized on by opportunistic demagogues and politicians turning one swath of the population against another. Such resentment towards other members in society is not conducive to a culture of collaboration necessary for complex undertakings.

In order to demonstrate the consequences of the incentive structure, consider a paradigm diametrically opposed to merit, where candidates for desired positions are selected based on the lowest ability. How are individuals incentivized to act in response? They will be unlikely to better themselves, as there is no incentive to improve themselves relative to their peers. It is more likely that individuals will purposefully lower their competence, ability, and skills in order to be selected for the desired position. In this paradigm, the aggregate ability of the population is lowered in response to the selection criteria. Instead of simply being zero sum, the situation becomes negative sum, making everyone worse off as a result.

Conversely, under a merit driven system, individuals will be incentivized to better themselves in pursuit of admittance to a university or being hired for a particular job. Even for individuals who fail to be selected, this is still beneficial, as they have learned new skills and honed others that are potentially transferable to other domains and occupations. Non-meritocratic policies and preferences that have been embraced throughout American history fall somewhere on the spectrum in between these two extremes. The selection of Navy Seals lies at one end while slavery and racially exclusionary policies lie at the other. The current admittance process for universities is somewhere in between, as merit is considered but is distorted through preferences for disadvantaged groups or diverse candidates.

When merit is not pursued as the sole qualification it creates a disconnect between the value of a selective position and what that occupation produces. This pattern is not unique to the United States and has been seen in several countries around the world. In Sri Lanka, for example, one observer commented that, “Work here is a matter of fulfilling a role, having a title and a position detached from what you produce or how you perform. A job here is about fulfilling obligations on the surface with little sense of the substance underneath it.” Another example from Argentina reported that, “only rarely will competence or training outweigh other, personal considerations in the appointment of public administrative officers or in the recruitment of managerial cadres in industry, business, or social organizations (unions, for instance).” Both examples are from countries that long struggled to develop economically. The cultural disconnect between merit and selective positions had serious economic consequences for the development of both nations.

In summary, we must be unapologetically meritocratic as the problems before us are daunting. These challenges demand the best of what we have to offer, and in response we must put forward our best; the best engineers, researchers, and entrepreneurs. We cannot hope to get back to the future while we are distracted by partisan games attempting to balance cosmic scales in the adjudication of historical grievances, often between groups that were never persecutors nor victims. As individuals, we must revere those with merit and aspire to their level. When we celebrate and promote merit, it not only raises the standards of what we achieve in the present but orients incentives towards a more productive future.

Notes

1

Job postings stating that, “no Irish need apply” is one of the most well known examples

2

Watson, M.S., 1950. Chief of Staff: Prewar plans and preparations (Vol. 4). Historical Division, Department of the Army. Pg 250

3

Mac Donald, H., 2018. The diversity delusion: How race and gender pandering corrupt the university and undermine our culture. St. Martin’s Press. Pg 94

4

Dushkin, L., 1979. Backward class benefits and social class in India, 1920-1970. Economic and Political Weekly, pp.661-667.